The article is written in connection with our "How Many Slices in a Loaf of Bread Calculator".
In a recent study, researchers tested whether simple changes in how bread is displayed in supermarkets could influence consumers to choose healthier, whole grain bread over white bread. Their findings were surprising.
When you think about the choices you make in a supermarket, you might not realize how much the layout influences what ends up in your cart. Behavioral economists call this nudging, where simple adjustments to product placement can supposedly steer consumers towards healthier decisions without them even noticing. But does it work?
A research team from the Netherlands sought to answer this question in an in-store experiment on bread sales. They placed healthier whole grain bread in a prominent, easy-to-reach spot in one condition and at the far end of the bread aisle in another. Shoppers passed through the bread section either encountering the whole grain options first or last.
Surprisingly, the results didn’t show a noticeable difference in sales between the two setups. “The accessibility of whole grain bread did not significantly influence consumers' purchase decisions,” the researchers noted. This suggests that when it comes to something as habitual as buying bread, simple nudges may not be enough to shift behavior.
As society continues to grapple with public health issues like obesity and poor diet, finding effective ways to promote healthier eating habits is crucial. This study highlights that while nudging has potential, it may not be a one-size-fits-all solution. When it comes to bread, preferences are deeply ingrained, and it seems that people are likely to stick to their usual choices, no matter where the healthier options are placed.
However, the researchers acknowledge that this experiment is just one step. “Further research is needed to better understand the complexity of consumer behavior and the effectiveness of nudges in various food categories,” they said. For now, it appears that changing habits takes more than simply rearranging the shelves.
The idea of nudging towards healthier choices is appealing, but it may need a bit more push when it comes to influencing long-standing consumer habits like bread purchases. While this experiment didn’t show significant results, it opens the door to further exploration into how we can better design environments to support healthier eating.
Source: René A. de Wijk, Anna J. Maaskant, Ilse A. Polet, Nancy T. E. Holthuysen, Ellen van Kleef, Monique H. Vingerhoeds, "An In-Store Experiment on the Effect of Accessibility on Sales of Wholegrain and White Bread in Supermarkets," PLOS ONE.